Buying Guides

Blackout Shades vs. Blackout Curtains: Which Works Better?

Blackout shades and blackout curtains can both darken a room, but their performance depends on the fabric, fit and installation. Compare the two options and learn when layering both works best.

  • Updated Nov 2026
  • 4 min read
Dark floor-to-ceiling drapes in a lounge

Blackout Shades vs. Blackout Curtains

If the goal is a darker bedroom, both blackout shades and blackout curtains can work very well.

The main difference is how they cover the window.

Blackout shades sit close to the glass.

Blackout curtains extend beyond the window opening.

Because of that, each solution has different strengths.

What Are Blackout Shades?

Blackout shades use opaque material designed to prevent light from passing through the fabric.

Common versions include:

They provide a clean, compact appearance and can be particularly useful in modern interiors.

Blackout roller shade lowered in a bedroom

What Are Blackout Curtains?

Blackout curtains use opaque fabric or a blackout lining.

Unlike shades, the fabric extends beyond the actual glass.

Curtains can therefore cover a larger portion of the wall around the window.

They also add:

  • texture
  • softness
  • decorative colour
  • visual height
Charcoal blackout curtains in a double-height room

Blackout Shades vs. Curtains: Key Differences

FeatureBlackout ShadesBlackout Curtains
PositionClose to the windowExtends around the window
AppearanceClean and compactSoft and decorative
Light Through FabricVery lowVery low with proper lining
Edge LightCan enter through side gapsCan be reduced by overlapping the window
Space RequiredMinimalRequires stacking space
MotorizationCommonAvailable with motorized tracks
LayeringWorks well with curtainsWorks well over shades

Which Makes a Room Darker?

The fabric is only part of the equation.

Even a very effective blackout shade can allow light through gaps around the sides.

Curtains may cover those gaps better if they:

  • extend above the window
  • extend beyond both sides
  • reach the floor
  • overlap appropriately

For maximum darkness, combining blackout shades and blackout curtains can be extremely effective.

What Is Light Leakage?

Light leakage is light that enters around rather than through the window treatment.

Common areas include:

  • sides
  • top
  • bottom
  • gaps between adjacent treatments

The amount depends on:

  • mounting method
  • window depth
  • hardware
  • product construction

If darkness is critical, discuss installation details rather than focusing only on whether the material says “blackout.”

Which Is Better for Bedrooms?

Both are excellent bedroom options.

Blackout shades are useful when you want:

  • clean appearance
  • compact installation
  • easy operation
  • motorization

Blackout curtains are useful when you want:

  • decorative fabric
  • softer room design
  • more coverage around the opening
  • additional layering
Bedroom with blackout drapes over sheers

Which Is Better for Condos?

Blackout shades often work well in condos because they use very little space.

This can be important around:

  • floor-to-ceiling windows
  • narrow window frames
  • balcony doors

Curtains can still work very well, especially with ceiling-mounted tracks.

They can also soften the appearance of large areas of glass.

Do Blackout Curtains Help With Temperature?

Curtains create an additional fabric layer between the room and window.

Depending on the fabric, lining and installation, this may help reduce heat transfer.

Some shade styles, particularly cellular shades, are also specifically designed to improve insulation.

Do not assume every product labeled blackout provides the same thermal performance.

Blackout describes light control, not necessarily insulation.

What About Noise?

Heavy curtains may slightly soften room acoustics and absorb some reflected sound.

However, ordinary blackout curtains should not be treated as a true soundproofing solution.

Reducing outside noise requires addressing the window, seals and building construction itself.

Can Both Be Motorized?

Yes.

Blackout shades are commonly available with motorized controls.

Curtains can also operate using motorized tracks.

Motorization is particularly useful for:

  • large windows
  • wide bedrooms
  • high windows
  • smart-home routines

Is Layering Both Worth It?

It can be.

A common setup is:

  • Blackout shade: handles most light control
  • Curtains: cover edge gaps and provide decorative softness

During the day the curtains can remain open and the shade can be adjusted independently.

At night both can be closed.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose blackout shades when you prefer:

  • minimal appearance
  • compact installation
  • motorization
  • simple operation

Choose blackout curtains when you prefer:

  • decorative fabric
  • more wall coverage
  • softer styling

Use both when maximum darkness and design flexibility are priorities.

Final Thoughts

Neither option automatically blocks more light.

Installation matters just as much as fabric.

A properly fitted blackout shade may outperform poorly installed curtains, while wide blackout curtains can cover gaps that a standard shade leaves exposed.

For the darkest result, consider how the entire window opening is covered.

Related guides

Ready to Find the Right
Window Treatments for Your Home?

Toronto Window Treatments offers professional measuring, product selection and installation for all types of blinds, shades, curtains and motorized solutions.

Visit Toronto Window Treatments (opens in a new tab)
Living room with floor-length curtains and armchairs